Two Birthmoms…Our Heroes

color family pic
It was Mother’s Day 1995. Another childless year had gone by and another Mother’s Day sought to remind me I was nobody’s mom. I felt invisible in a crowd of corsages and illegibly handwritten cards declaring love for Mommy. I sat in church crying the same tears I had cried every year on this day…and praying the same prayer, “Oh God, if it could be your will, PLEASE just give us a child.”

As the pastor began to speak of the love and admiration we should show to moms, I felt my husband’s arm around me. It was his silent way of saying, “I feel your pain too. I want you to be a mom.” It reminded me of what a sensitive dad he would be. We prayed daily for a baby. But, in the course of six years, every pregnancy test had been negative and every year brought more discouragement. We knew God knew the future and had a plan, but to our human understanding He often seemed silent. Painfully silent. How could I have known that beyond our little world were two women whose love and courage would change our lives forever?

It was the Fall of 1994 when we first contacted an agency in our area to talk about adoption possibilities. The moment we met our counselor, we were impressed. Her enthusiasm lit up the room. She understood our financial situation and decided to trust God with us that if it was His will for us to adopt, He would provide along the way. He did so miraculously and we were approved by February of 1995. Then came the waiting. We had waited so many years. We joked that waiting had become our specialty.

In January of 1996, it appeared the waiting might soon be over. Our counselor told us a birthmom named Karen had chosen our profile page and would be calling us that night. The moment we heard her voice, we liked her. She was articulate and kind. She asked a lot of questions and we could tell she loved this baby intensely. He was two months old now. At the time of his birth, she had been unsure of whether she was going to place for adoption or parent so she placed him in a loving foster home while trying to come to a final decision. She had chosen now to seek an adoptive couple and wanted to meet with us as soon as possible. The meeting we had with her and later with both her and her parents confirmed to us that God had not been silent all those years. No. He had heard every word…responded to every prayer. His timing was flawless.

Karen was 21 and in college. She and her parents had agreed on adoption and had prayed for a Christian couple. She said the moment she saw our picture she knew we were the ones. Only God could cause such an ordinary-looking couple to seem extraordinary to her. As she read our profile, the decision was confirmed. The birthfather was supportive of the adoptive plan though he chose not to meet us.

The moment we first met I reached out to hug her and can still remember thinking, “This is the woman we have prayed for.” We met our son a few days later. Like every set of new parents, we thought he was more glorious than any baby we had previously seen.

In fact, after the first meeting with him, I called a friend and said, “I’d just like to apologize.” With confusion my friend asked, “Apologize? Apologize for what?”

“I want to apologize for all the times I said your little baby was the sweetest baby on earth. Without even knowing it, I lied. Today we met the sweetest baby on earth.”

Stephen became our son January 23, 1996, the day he turned three months old. The dream had become reality. Phil was a real dad. I was a real mom.

As we watched Stephen blow out the candles on his second birthday cake, we said, “Thank you, God, for this beautiful son…and could you give him a baby brother or sister?” Should we dare to even dream for a SECOND miracle? Trusting God’s timing, we began to pray daily that God would provide a baby, if it was His will.

Less than three months later, the phone rang. My husband’s mom had been showing off pictures of her grandkids, when one of the observers said, “Are Philip and Lisa wanting to adopt again?” Philip’s mom said an enthused, “YES!”

She (my mother-n-law’s friend) worked with a woman who had told her just that week that she had decided to place her soon-to-be-delivered baby for adoption and was looking for a Christian couple. The birthmom called us a few days later to set up a meeting. She lived a few hours away and was 35 years old, a college graduate, single mom of a 12-year-old. We met her at the favorite meeting place for all parents…McDonalds. Cathy would turn out to be God’s next blessing in our lives.

She was pleasant and kind but was obviously tired. Seeing Cathy actually carrying the child in her body helped me realize again what love both these women had for these babies. They nurtured and cared for them for nine long months. Her 12-year-old supported the decision to place for adoption. The birthfather too agreed with the decision though chose not to meet us. She asked lots of questions and even made notes in a spiral notebook. As we were leaving, she told us to drive by the hospital…so we would know where to come when she called. This was her way of saying she liked us. Two days later she called and confirmed her decision to place the child with us.

The next few days were spent getting legal paper work set up and trying to prepare for a new member of the family. Three weeks after our meeting, she called Philip from the hospital only minutes after giving birth to say, “Hey Dad! You should come see this beautiful boy!”

He was indeed beautiful in every way. The time spent with Cathy and her family at the hospital the next 24 hours was precious. We met her parents, son, and brother. I’ll never forget a walk I took with her around the hospital that night. I told her the same thing we had told Karen. We wanted the absolute BEST for her and for her beautiful baby. If she decided to parent, we would understand, love her, and support her decision. We held hands and both had a good cry. She held fast to her original decision and the next day found us crying and hugging as we all prepared to go our separate ways. Jonathan has been a blessing and a JOY to our hearts. We are still amazed that God said, “yes” twice! It is often said, “God moves in mysterious ways.” Our lives have been a testimony of such. On more than one occasion, we have said, “God, thank you. Thank you for the terrible waiting, the wondering, the negative pregnancy tests, the searching…and the provision that has been beyond what we could have ever hoped for.”

We also thank Him for these two loving and courageous women. How could we begin to say thank you to the women who carried and nurtured our sons before we even knew them? How could we begin to say thank you to them for choosing life? For understanding the meaning of the word sacrifice? For loving the boys beyond what most people will ever understand?

Our family tree is now blessed with two fine sons. But always at the roots will be Karen and Cathy…our family heroes.
*The birthmoms’ names have been changed in respect of their privacy.
“Like” Lisa Smartt’s FB author page at:

IMG_8319 copy-2

14 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. Amy
    Jan 23, 2015 @ 14:48:26

    What a wonderful post. I love hearing others adoption stories. Thank you for sharing Lisa.


  2. Wanda Gargus
    Jan 23, 2015 @ 15:17:53

    Lisa, I enjoy reading your post and articles so very much. I am so glad that you were able to become a mom. I remember feeling that way about becoming a grandmother. For years my daughter wasn’t able to have children. We finally have two wonderful grandchildren who are more precious than gold!!! Wanda Gargus


  3. Susan Kelly
    Jan 23, 2015 @ 16:10:25

    What a wonderful mother those boys were given….twice. What a sweet all that you write..


  4. Grace N
    Jan 23, 2015 @ 19:10:52

    I cried a few tears reading this Lisa and remembering that day you found out that Stephen was going to be coming home to you and Phillip! I remember the fun getting ready for his homecoming was… and I was so incredibly happy for you and thank God for His gifts He’s given! Before you know it… you might hear some little voices saying “grandma” and in a blink of an eye… they’ll be driving, have a job, and so it goes on! It’s exciting to see what God has in store for these special boys who grew up with the absolute best parents!!!!

    Love you guys and miss ya!


    • thesmarttview
      Jan 23, 2015 @ 19:43:26

      Oh Grace, you were such a help and encouragement during that time! Sure wish we could see you guys! We have such sweet memories of our time with you and your amazing family!!


  5. Becky Gookin
    Jan 23, 2015 @ 20:48:54

    Such a beautiful and loving story my friend. And those boys are amazing!!!


  6. Casey jo
    Jan 23, 2015 @ 21:20:15

    This just brings tears to my eyes! I know this feeling exactly! After what seemed like a lifetime of praying to be a mom my husband and I were blessed with a sweet baby boy. Now I find myself praying and longing for another baby but wondering if it’s selfish to ask for another baby!! I’m glad I’m not the only adoptive parent that feels guilty to ask God to give us another child. I am so grateful that our sons bm chose us!!


    • thesmarttview
      Jan 27, 2015 @ 09:33:59

      Casey Jo,

      Thanks so much for sharing your story! As to praying for a second blessing, worry not! Pray, pray, pray, sister! 🙂 God has no shortage of blessings. I’m SO thankful that you were able to become a mom. I know what that was like. I’m thankful with you and for you!


  7. Jamie McCrory
    Jan 27, 2015 @ 09:27:15

    So nice to read such a sweet story. As an adopted daughter that has lost her mom I couldn’t help but shed some tears from so many memories of my mothers stories of yearning for motherhood! I always felt like she never took a day of being a mother for granted. I held her hand as she passed on Lisa, and there is no doubt in my mind that I was the daughter God had planned for her.


    • thesmarttview
      Jan 27, 2015 @ 09:35:55

      Oh Jamie,

      You’re gonna make a big girl cry!!! 🙂 I loved hearing your story. I’m sorry about your mom’s death, but I’m glad God gave her to you…and you to her. His provision never ceases to AMAZE me.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: